![]() |
| Muscles are layered and connected. Which muscle is the root of pain? Which muscle do you want to fix? |
When a patient points to one muscle and says,
This is where my problem is.
that location is clinically important.
But it may only be the most noticeable part of a much larger process.
Muscles do not work independently. They constantly adjust their activity with other muscles to produce movement, maintain stability, and respond to changing physical demands.
So what happens when one part of this system can no longer perform its role effectively?
To understand this, it helps to look at several concepts commonly discussed in motor-control research.
Motor Control: The Body Has to Organize Movement
Motor control refers to how the nervous system organizes and regulates movement.
Movement is not simply the result of individual muscles contracting.
The nervous system has to coordinate multiple muscles and joints while responding to the task, the environment, and sensory information from the body.
This creates an important problem.
There are far more muscles and possible combinations of muscle activity than are strictly necessary to perform a single movement.
Researchers sometimes refer to this as the degrees-of-freedom problem.
The nervous system therefore needs a way to organize this complexity.
One proposed solution is the use of muscle synergies.
Muscle Synergy: Muscles Working as a Coordinated Group
A muscle synergy is a way of describing groups of muscles whose activity is coordinated to help accomplish a particular movement or maintain stability.
Instead of controlling every muscle completely independently, the nervous system can coordinate groups of muscles as functional units.
This does not mean that the muscles always activate at exactly the same time or with exactly the same amount of force.
Rather, their activity can be coordinated according to the demands of the task.
This concept becomes particularly interesting when pain or dysfunction is introduced.
A systematic review examining musculoskeletal pain found consistent evidence that muscle synergies in painful conditions can differ from those observed in pain-free conditions. However, the specific changes were not uniform across studies. (PubMed Central (PMC))
That distinction is important.
It suggests that pain can be associated with a change in the organization of muscle control, rather than simply causing one muscle to become “tight.”
Motor Recruitment: Who Is Doing the Work?
Another important term is motor recruitment.
Recruitment describes how the nervous system activates motor units and organizes muscle activity to produce the force required for a task.
But recruitment is not simply:
Muscle A = ON
Muscle B = OFF
The nervous system can change:
- how much activity a muscle produces,
- when it becomes active,
- how long it remains active,
- how its activity is coordinated with other muscles.
This means that when one muscle cannot contribute normally, the response may involve changes across several muscles, rather than a simple replacement of one muscle by another.
Experimental pain research has demonstrated that pain can alter motor control at multiple levels and that movement performance may be maintained partly through redistribution of muscle activity. (PubMed)
Redistribution of Muscle Activity
This concept is particularly relevant to clinical practice.
Redistribution of muscle activity means that the contribution to a task can shift between muscles—or even between different regions within the same muscle.
For example, when pain is introduced into one muscle, researchers have observed changes in how muscular effort is distributed among muscles involved in the task. (Physiology Journals)
This gives us a more sophisticated way to think about compensation.
It is not necessarily:
Muscle A stopped working, so Muscle B took over.
It may be:
The contribution of several muscles changed as the nervous system reorganized the movement strategy.
That is a very different concept.
Motor Adaptation: The Body Is Trying to Solve a Problem
This brings us to motor adaptation.
When pain, injury, fatigue, or altered function changes the demands of a movement, the nervous system may modify the way the movement is performed.
Sometimes this adaptation is protective.
Sometimes it allows a person to continue performing a task despite pain.
And sometimes, if the altered strategy persists, it may create new mechanical or muscular demands.
Research on experimental pain has shown that pain can produce protective and compensatory changes in motor behavior, while still allowing many motor tasks to be completed. (PubMed)
This is why I don't automatically consider an altered muscle pattern to be “wrong.”
The body may be solving a problem.
The more important clinical question is:
Is the adaptation still useful, or has it become part of what is maintaining the problem?
When One Part of the System Changes
Now we can return to the original question.
What happens when one muscle cannot perform its role effectively?
The answer is not necessarily that another muscle simply takes over.
Instead, the nervous system may change the organization of the movement.
One muscle may contribute less. Another may contribute more. Activation may occur at a different time.
Several muscles may change their coordination.
The distribution of muscular effort may shift.
And the overall movement strategy may change.
In other words:
One local change can produce a system-level adaptation.
That adaptation may be subtle enough that the patient never notices the original change.
They may only notice the muscle that eventually becomes painful, fatigued, or persistently active.
The Muscle You Feel May Be the Result, Not the Beginning
This is where I believe clinical examination becomes particularly important.
A patient may tell me:
This muscle is always tight.
But instead of immediately asking how to make that muscle relax, I want to ask:
Why is this muscle being asked to contribute so much?
Is it actually the primary problem?
Is another region contributing differently?
Has pain changed the patient's movement?
Has the distribution of muscle activity changed?
Is the muscle responding to increased demand?
Or is the problem simply local?
There is no universal answer.
But these questions prevent us from assuming that the most symptomatic muscle is automatically the source of the problem.
Why This Changes the Way I Treat
If a muscle is working harder because the movement system has adapted to another problem, repeatedly reducing the activity of that muscle may reduce the symptom without changing the reason for the increased demand.
That does not mean soft-tissue treatment, stretching, or other symptom-relieving treatments are useless.
They can have an appropriate role.
But I don't want symptom reduction to be the end of the assessment.
I want to understand what created the need for that muscle to work differently in the first place.
Because sometimes the most important finding is not:
This muscle is overactive.
but:
Why has the system decided that this muscle needs to be overactive?
Beyond the Muscle
The body is not a collection of independent muscles.
It is a coordinated system.
When one part changes, the nervous system may adjust how other parts contribute.
That adjustment may be temporary.
It may be protective.
It may be helpful.
Or, under some circumstances, it may contribute to persistent symptoms.
That is why I try to look beyond the muscle that hurts.
I don't just want to know which muscle is working too hard. I want to understand why the system is asking it to work so hard.
That is where the examination becomes more than simply finding a painful muscle.
It becomes an attempt to understand how the movement system is functioning as a whole.
References
1. Liew BXW, Del Vecchio A, Falla D.
The influence of musculoskeletal pain disorders on muscle synergies—A systematic review. PLOS ONE. 2018;13(11):e0206885. [PubMed] [Full Article]
The influence of musculoskeletal pain disorders on muscle synergies—A systematic review. PLOS ONE. 2018;13(11):e0206885. [PubMed] [Full Article]
2. Hug F, Hodges PW, van den Hoorn W, Tucker K.
Between-muscle differences in the adaptation to experimental pain. Journal of Applied Physiology. 2014;117(10):1132–1140. [PubMed] [DOI]
3. Hug F, Hodges PW, Tucker K.
Effect of pain location on spatial reorganisation of muscle activity. Journal of Electromyography and Kinesiology. 2013;23(6):1413–1420. [PubMed] [DOI]
4. Hodges PW, Tucker K.
A mechanism-based classification of muscle activation changes during acute and chronic low back pain. Pain. 2011;152(7):1470–1482. [PubMed] [DOI]
The information provided on this blog is for educational and informational purposes only and should not be construed as professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Reading this content does not establish a doctor-patient relationship between you and Rapha Chiropractic & Acupuncture, PLLC. Always seek the advice of your physician or other qualified health provider with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition. Never disregard professional medical advice or delay in seeking it because of something you have read on this blog.

Post a Comment